Plagiocephaly Clinical Research

Plagiocephaly Clinical Research

In the UK, there have been few, if any, academic or clinical papers published about plagiocephaly. As you may be aware, the NHS does not regard plagiocephaly as a medical condition and, therefore, head shapes are not measured at birth, or, indeed, subsequently.

There is, therefore, no academic incentive to begin a study of the condition or the different effects of treatments/therapies that are available. We have had to look elsewhere for relevant research and have tried to pick out those which offer some measurable evidence for their conclusions.

We have written a short summary and then provided a link to the paper in question for those who wish to download the whole paper (please be aware that in some cases the publication will charge a fee for this service).

Effectiveness of Conservative Therapy and Helmet Therapy For Positional Cranial Deformation

This is a retrospective study of the effectiveness of treatment for 4,378 babies between 2004 and 2011 at the Children’s Memorial Hospital, Chicago, Illinois. It compares conservative treatment (repositioning with or without physiotherapy) and helmet therapy for plagiocephaly and brachycephaly. The research paper was published in March 2015 in the Journal of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery.

Results

Complete correction was achieved in 77.1% of conservative treatment patients, 15.8% required transition to helmet therapy and 7.1% ultimately had incomplete correction.

For babies who received helmet therapy as first-line therapy, the complete correction was achieved in 94.4% of cases and in 96.1% of infants that received helmet therapy after the failure of conservative therapy.

The babies in the helmet group on average started with more severe head and neck deformity and were older than the babies in the conservatively treated group.

LOC Comments

This is the biggest research sample to date. The initial treatment regime was jointly agreed upon by health professionals and parents.

The authors have identified risk factors for failure of conservative treatment:

  • poor compliance;
  • advanced age of baby;
  • prolonged torticollis;
  • the severity of the initial cranial ratio;
  • developmental delay.

Risk factors for failure of helmet treatment were:

  • poor compliance;
  • advanced age of the baby.

This study confirms our clinician’s view that helmet therapy is the correct treatment for babies with moderate to severe plagiocephaly or brachycephaly, but repositioning does work for young babies with mild cranial deformation.

A full abstract of the research paper can be downloaded for free. 

 

Treatment of positional plagiocephaly – helmet or no helmet?

To our knowledge, this recently published study is based on the largest sample to date comparing babies who received helmet therapy treatment with those that did not. This research supports our long held clinical opinion that helmet therapy is an appropriate and successful treatment for babies with moderate and severe plagiocephaly

A total of 128 infants were enrolled in this prospective, non-randomized, longitudinal study. Of those, 62 were treated with and 66 without a helmet. Although the babies who received treatment had more severe asymmetry initially, they showed significantly better improvement (68% vs. 31%). 

 

Possible link of cognitive and motor delays in babies with ‘flat head syndrome’

In a study published in March 2010 in pediatrics, infants averaging six months of age who exhibited positional plagiocephaly had lower scores than typical infants in observational tests to evaluate cognitive and motor development. In the study conducted by Seattle Children’s Research Institute 472 babies were screened, half had been diagnosed with some level of’ ‘flat head syndrome’ and half were a 'normal' control group. The study found that those babies who exhibited some degree of flatness at the back of the head were more likely to perform worse on motor test functions by an average of 10%.

Though the findings indicated an association between flat head syndrome and developmental delay, that does not necessarily indicate a direct causal link. Indeed, there could be a reverse correlation – babies with pre-existing motor delays are more likely to end up with flatter heads because they move less and remain in one position for longer periods of time.

 

Risk factors for deformational plagiocephaly at birth and at seven weeks of age

A total of 400 healthy babies were measured within 48 hours of birth and then at seven weeks at a General District Hospital in the Netherlands in 2004/5. Twenty (5%) of the children were lost to follow-up for a variety of reasons, so 380 babies could be analysed at the follow-up stage.

At birth, 23 (6%) babies presented with deformational plagiocephaly. At seven weeks, only nine of these still had deformational plagiocephaly. However, in another 75 babies, plagiocephaly developed between birth and follow-up. So, at the age of seven weeks, a total of 84 babies from a sample of 380 had plagiocephaly (22%).

This study would suggest that the primary cause of plagiocephaly is positional and perhaps we ought to distinguish between it and deformational plagiocephaly (which is caused by something that happens during the birth process).

 

Incidence of otitis media in children with deformational plagiocephaly

The purpose of this study in 2009 was to determine if there is an increased risk of the development of otitis media (ear infection) in children with the diagnosis of deformational plagiocephaly.

The study did not show a statistically significant increase in the incidence of otitis media among the study group of 1,259 patients, compared to the national average. However, among 124 patients, changes in ear pressure were studied with the use of tympanometry, which is a tool that provides quantitative information on the presence of middle ear fluid. In this sample, deformational plagiocephaly was directly correlated with otitis media. The more severe cases of deformational plagiocephaly had a higher percentage of otitis media than the less severe cases.

Plagiocephaly FAQS:

This is very much dependent on how fast your baby is growing. The faster the growth, the more frequently your baby will be seen so that the helmet can be adjusted. In general, reviews will happen at two to four-week intervals.

The price of treatment covers:

  • all your baby’s required appointments from start to the end of treatment, no matter how many are required to achieve the improvement in head shape that you are happy with;
  • the cost of manufacturing the LOCband and supply of appropriate cleaning fluid for the band;
  • all reports to your GP/paediatrician/ cranial osteopath/physiotherapist, including a final scan report with objective measurements of change achieve;
  • full telephone support from your clinician during treatment, and, if necessary, extra review appointments at short notice.

Yes - All babies that have completed their course of treatment with us have achieved a measurable improvement in head shape. However, you don’t have to take our word for it.

Recent independent research conducted by a University Hospital in Germany has endorsed the treatment for babies with moderate or severe plagiocephaly.

A larger, retrospective study has just been published that found complete correction was achieved in 94.4% of babies treated with helmet therapy.

The results were conclusive: repositioning achieved acceptable correction in 77.1% of cases, but 15.8% were moved onto helmet therapy because re-positioning was not working. Meanwhile, 94.4% of the infants who started in the helmet-treated group achieved full correction, as did 96.1% of those who were transferred from the repositioning group into the helmet-treated group.

Further information can be found on our Plagiocephaly Research page.

If your baby has a temperature or a fever due to illness you must remove the band. The band can be put back on once the temperature has returned to normal.

The optimum age for treatment is between four and seven months.

This is because the skull is most malleable at this age and improvements to head shape tend to take less time and are more dramatic. That is not to say that helmet therapy should be ruled out if the baby is older than seven months. Routinely, babies up to the age of 16 months can be treated very successfully.

The cut off age is around 18 months when the fontanelles (soft spots on the head) are no longer malleable. As babies grow and develop at different rates, it is always worth checking if you are not sure. There have been cases where a baby’s fontanelles have not fused yet by the age of 18 months, who have achieved successful, but less-marked results with cranial remoulding therapy.

Torticollis is a condition in which a tight or shortened muscle in one side of the neck causes the head to tilt or turn to one side, resulting in the infant resting its head in the same position. In 2013, we analysed the data from all first appointments in our Kingston clinic and found that 20% of the babies examined had some kind of neck condition that was causing head immobility.

The clinics and clinicians that provide this treatment in the UK will have received similar training and experience. However, we are the only clinic that manufactures its own helmet and our clinicians are closely involved with the process for each individual helmet that we produce.

In addition, we do not restrict review appointments to a set number, we are extremely flexible and respond to individual parents' needs so that the best outcome can be achieved for each baby.

The LOCband is non-invasive and works by applying gentle, constant pressure over the areas of the baby’s skull that are most prominent while allowing unrestricted growth over the flattened areas. The band consists of a soft foam layer inside a thermoplastic shell. As the baby grows, the band will be adjusted frequently to gently guide the skull into a more symmetrical shape.

RECENT POSTS

Cat Hendy nominated for BAPO student of the year

Apprentice orthotist Catherine Hendy’s journey into the world of prosthetics and orthotics began in an unconventional way. After completing a degree in art, she then trained as an orthotics technician, before taking up an apprenticeship to become a clinician. Now, she’s been nominated for the British Association of Prosthetists and Orthotists (BAPO) Student of the Year 2024.

Amelia's plagiocephaly journey

Amelia was diagnosed with tightness in her neck by her GP before her plagiocephaly diagnosis. Clinician Jo Drake treated her with a LOCband Lite cranial remoulding helmet, which improved her overall head shape and asymmetry.

Guide to lower limb orthotics

What are lower limb orthotics, and how can they improve mobility and reduce pain? We've put together this summary of the different kinds of lower limb orthotics, from AFOs and KAFOs to more complex orthotics like RGOs, and how they can help patients with their mobility goals.

Barney's plagiocephaly journey

Barney's very severe flat head syndrome (plagiocephaly) and diagnosis of torticollis led to successful helmet therapy with the LOCband, significantly improving his head shape, going from 27mm asymmetry to 12mm.

Pectus bracing treatment improves Aris' complex chest deformity

“It’s life-changing, my swimming coach has even remarked what a difference my treatment has made" Read how pectus bracing treatment helped to correct Aris' complex chest deformity, involving a combination of pectus excavatum, pectus carinatum and rib flaring.

 Lucas's walking improves after just six months in his new AFOs

Cerebral palsy patient Lucas sees significant improvement in his walking after only six months in his new custom Ankle Foot Orthoses (AFOs), designed by Professor Saeed Forghany in our Manchester clinic. Hear how a detailed gait analysis and bespoke AFOs significantly improved Lucas's gait and comfort.

Freddie's plagiocephaly journey

Freddie’s positional plagiocephaly was treated successfully with the LOCBand Lite, going from 11mm to 2mm after four months in his helmet.

Natasha can walk again thanks to her new orthotics

Adult club foot (talipes) patient Natasha says, "I cannot stress how amazing my AFOs are and how they have changed so much for me. The support they give me allows me to walk without crutches outside the house for the first time in over fifteen years."

Pevious Next

For Plagiocephaly free photo diagnosis, please upload images in accordance with our plagiocephaly photo guide (max. 2mb each).

For Pectus, please follow our pectus photo guide (max 2mb each).